Date Presented 04/20/2023
This quasi-experimental study completed at six skilled nursing facilities (SNFs) found statistically significant improvements in self-care utilizing an evidence-based group protocol that included fine motor, cognition, strength, flexibility, balance, and occupational components.
Primary Author and Speaker: Melissa K Luchynsky
Contributing Authors: Katie Ashbaugh, Amber Bowser, Emily Campisi, Morgan Gleixner, Byron Heinbach, Allison Snak
PURPOSE: A new payment model enables OTs working in skilled nursing facilities (SNFs) to provide up to 25% of treatment (tx) in group settings despite limited research in this area. Researchers inquired, will patients participating in individual and group tx sessions in SNFs have the same/better or worse functional outcomes than those receiving only individualized OT? Are patients satisfied with this approach?
DESIGN: This quasi-experimental, two-tailed research study recruited patients with orders for group and individualized OT sessions in six SNFs. Data mining enabled formation of a comparison group with similar baseline characteristics receiving only 1:1 sessions.
METHOD: An a priori power analysis revealed a need for 74-148 participants to achieve data saturation. Six researchers completed literature reviews on fine motor, balance, strength, cognition, flexibility, and occupation-based activities to develop an evidence-based group protocol which they provided up to 1x/week for a maximum of 10 weeks. Researchers extracted CARE Item Set data from 85 experimental participants’ OT eval and d/c reports and administered a Likert-based satisfaction survey to the experimental group after an individual and group session. Data analyzed using a two-tailed t-test to compare scores.
RESULTS: N=85 (24 males, 61 females; age range 51-96 y/o). CARE Item scores showed a statistically significant improvement in self-care (p-value=0.0069) and a nonsignificant improvement in functional mobility (p-value=0.5887) for experimental vs comparison group. Experimental group: 60% of participants satisfied with 1:1 tx, 76% satisfied with group tx.
CONCLUSION: Replacing one 1:1 tx session per week with an EBP OT group session yielded same or better improvements in self-care performance when compared to those receiving only 1:1 sessions. Group participants had the same or better satisfaction with group. OTs may use findings to make informed clinical decisions about group use in SNF settings.
Hammond, F., Barrett, R., Dijkers, M., Zanca, J., Horn, S., Smout, R., Guerrier, T., Hauser, E., & Dunning, M. (2015). Group therapy use and its impact on the outcomes of inpatient rehabilitation after traumatic brain injury: Data from traumatic brain injury-practice-based evidence project. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, 96(8), S282–92.e5. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apmr.2014.11.029
Tijsen, L., Derksen, E., Achterberg, W., & Buijck, B. (2019). Challenging rehabilitation environment for older patients. Clinical Interventions in Aging, 14, 1451–1460. https://doi.org/10.2147/CIA.S207
Zanca, J., Dijkers, M., Hsieh, C, Heinemann, A., Horn, S., Smout, R., & Backus, D. (2013). Group therapy utilization in inpatient spinal cord injury rehabilitation. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, 94(4), S145–S153. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apmr.2012.11.049
Kielhofner, G. (2009). The functional group model. In G. Kielhofner (Ed.), Conceptual foundations of occupational therapy practice (4th ed., pp.110-129). F. A. Davis Company.